With reports surfacing today that the Detroit Tigers and Tarik Skubal are approximately $250 million apart in contract extension talks, the possibility of trading their elite left‐hander is gaining serious traction.
If Detroit elects to move Skubal rather than watch him walk next offseason, they’ll likely demand a haul — premium young controllable talent across both pitching and position players. Below are five imaginative (but plausible) trade packages that contending clubs might offer — including one rumor involving Boston — and an analysis of their strengths and drawbacks.
1. Red Sox Offer: Casas + Tolle + Early
One speculative offer circulating has Boston sending Triston Casas, Payton Tolle, and Connelly Early to Detroit in exchange for Skubal.
-
Triston Casas: A high-upside corner bat with power potential, though he’s suffered injuries and inconsistency.
-
Payton Tolle: A very young lefty pitching arm who is beginning to make noise at higher levels.
-
Connelly Early: A promising left‐handed pitching prospect with strikeout ability and room to grow.
Pros for Detroit: They’d get a bat to plug into their future core, plus two pitchers with upside and control years. The mix of position and pitching helps balance risk.
Cons for Boston: Casas is somewhat brittle and might not reach star potential; trading two young arms for a one-year rental (unless extension is agreed) is risky. Also, Boston might be giving ground in pitching depth at a time when they may need it.
This kind of deal could entice Detroit — but it might not be enough unless bolstered with additional prospects or financial sweeteners (cash, picks, etc.).
Thoughts
👇🏽👇🏽👇🏽 pic.twitter.com/5AS7nHLgs9
— Master flip 🇩🇴 (@Masterflip_) October 17, 2025
2. Yankees Offer: Will Warren + Spencer Jones + Utility Bat + Draft Pick
New York is often quick to pounce on elite arms. A potential package: Will Warren (top pitching arm in their system), Spencer Jones (outfield/hitting prospect), plus a versatile position bat (say a high-end corner or middle-infielder) and a competitive draft pick or international pool bonus.
-
Strengths: The Yankees can supply multiple impact pieces; they have depth in both pitching and hitting to spare.
-
Risks: They must weigh giving up part of their future to land what may be a one-year rental (unless a Skubal extension is secured). Also, the Tigers may demand more pitching upside given the premium on starting arms.
3. Mets Offer: Two Young Arms + Position Prospect + Relief Piece
The Mets, needing rotation help, could offer something like two young pitchers (one high-upside, one close to MLB-ready), a promising position prospect (middle infield or corner bat), and a bullpen arm with controlled innings.
-
Upside: They maintain balance, giving Detroit both near-term and future pitching help. The inclusion of a position piece helps offset the loss of a bat in their system.
-
Challenges: They may have to part with arms they’d rather protect for their own future rotation. Also, the Tigers might push for a premium package given Skubal’s dominant resume.
-
4. San Francisco Giants
Offer: OF Heliot Ramos, RHP Mason Black, LHP Carson Whisenhunt
The Giants desperately need a headliner in both talent and star power.
-
Heliot Ramos finally broke through in 2025, flashing real middle-of-the-order ability.
-
Mason Black has MLB experience and projects as a solid No. 3 starter.
-
Carson Whisenhunt is a lefty with swing-and-miss stuff and high upside.
Why it works: San Francisco lands a true ace while keeping much of its farm intact. Detroit adds two young starters and a potential middle-order bat — exactly the type of balance they’re seeking.
-
5. Seattle Mariners
Proposed Offer: RHP Bryce Miller, OF Lazaro Montes, LHP Reid VanScoter
The Mariners won’t touch Julio Rodríguez, but they still have the talent to make an aggressive play.
-
Bryce Miller is a proven MLB starter with electric stuff and years of team control.
-
Lazaro Montes, Seattle’s top hitting prospect, offers massive raw power from the left side.
-
Reid VanScoter gives Detroit a controllable lefty with back-end rotation potential.
Why It Works: Detroit adds one MLB-ready arm and two intriguing young pieces, including a potential middle-of-the-order slugger in Montes. Seattle, meanwhile, gains the frontline ace needed to compete in a loaded AL West.
Which Trade Makes the Most Sense?
Of the five, the Red Sox deal (Casas + Tolle + Early) is the most realistic for a club with both pitching and hitting depth in its system. The Yankees and Mets offers are compelling if they’re willing to be aggressive. Ultimately, Detroit will hold the leverage, but if they decide not to bridge the $250 million gap, these are the types of offers they’ll demand to trade away one of baseball’s best arms.
5 Comments