On August 4th, the Yankees entered a new era of baseball. It’s not tied to their fancy trade deadline pickups, or even getting possibly the best right-handed hitter of all time back from injury.
Instead, it was a long-awaited positional change at the most prominent position on the field. When George Lombard Jr. took over shortstop duties, the New York front office made a clear statement— they want the best players on the field, right now.
The lead-up to the move
Prior to the bold promotion of Lombard, the Yankees had witnessed such an unfortunate story at shortstop. Anthony Volpe’s tenure in the Bronx is the sort of prospect horror story that leads a GM to be aggressive at a trade deadline.
New York selected Volpe 30th overall in the 2019 MLB draft. Two years later, he won the 2021 Hitting Prospect of the Year award, after posting an OPS over 1.000 over 109 games between Low and High-A. By 2023, he rose all the way to number five on MLB Pipeline’s Top 100 prospects list. With Isaiah Kiner-Falefa as his competitor, Volpe became the Yanks’ Opening Day shortstop that year.
The excitement following Volpe at the big league level can only be described as a failure of the analytics. In his rookie season, Volpe recorded a 20 homer, 20 stolen base season while adding +15 Defensive Runs Saved at shortstop.
His defensive efforts earned him a Gold Glove award in his rookie season, the first Yankee ever to do so. Under the heat of a franchise with high expectations and gaudy standards, most fans backed the youngster.
However, in reality Volpe’s rookie season OPS landed at .666, well below the league average of .734 in 2023. His deflated OPS was due to a poor .283 OBP that stemmed from a quiet .209 batting average.
Regardless, future shortstop duties belonged to Volpe after his stellar defensive year. According to Wins Above Replacement, Volpe posted an even 2 wins above replacement, which isn’t shiny but also isn’t a negative.
In 2024, the Yanks’ shortstop enjoyed his best year to date. He upped his average to .243 and posted a valuable +13 outs above average (Statcast). He totaled 3.5 WAR that year, mirroring the production of a Masyn Winn in 2025. Although the season ended a night later, Volpe’s World Series Game 4 grand slam highlighted his year individually.
Anthony Volpe GRAND SLAM!!!!!
The Yankee bats have come ALIVE in game 4pic.twitter.com/6p5TOTVYMa
— Big League Digest (@BigLeagueDigest) October 30, 2024
Unfortunately, 2024 looks like the peak of Volpe’s career in the present-day. He struggled mightily in 2025, batting .212 with an abysmal .272 OBP. The worst part came defensively, as Volpe regressed to a -5 Fielding Run Value, instantly erasing his value on the field. He failed to reach 20 homers or 20 stolen bases, and worst of all, it was another sub-.700 OPS season.
Volpe began 2026 on the injured list while he recovered from shoulder surgery, but his data didn’t vary much. Since returning, Volpe recorded his 2000th plate appearance in the big leagues. This marks an unfortunate achievement for Volpe:
Of 103 players to record 2000 plate appearances with the Yankees, Anthony Volpe has the lowest AVG and OBP out of all of them
That’s not quite where New York expected their top-prospect, wonderkid shortstop to end up.
The Lombard effect, on the field and in the front office
George Lombard Jr.’s career is off to a strong start, earning immediate praise from the Yankee faithful. However, it’s not just the on-field play that’s impacting the Yankees. Now that prospect call-up season is upon us, Lombard leads the way as the most counted-on name in the jar.
Already, Lombard is hitting .270 with two home runs and a strong .816 OPS. He’s picked up ten hits and five walks in 12 games. He’s not striking out too often, his walk rate is up above 10%, and his pitch selection looks advanced. He also clocked a 29.8 ft/s top sprint speed, landing him in the top 2% of all players.
Defensively, he’s making his biggest impact, compiling an unreal EIGHT Defensive Runs Saved in only twelve games. Comparing that to Volpe’s 15 DRS over a full season, Lombard is looking even more polished out of the gate. He’s turned 12 double plays already, a rate almost twice as good as Volpe’s.
However, the actual production is just the start of Lombard’s effect.
The Yankees went through an incredibly tough summer, lacking offensive firepower severely through most of June and July. Considered elite back in March, their offense had to add two key bats in Heliot Ramos and Luis Garcia Jr., seemingly just to hold pace.
The clear looming thought is the expected return of Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, and Cody Bellinger to the roster. Judge has just begun swinging again, and Bellinger figures to return within the week. Meanwhile, New York expects Stanton to return in early September.
The vision is clear: once New York gets healthy, they feel like they’re the team to beat in the American League. While the Tampa Bay Rays are eyeing a potential number one seed, the Yankees feel that the most talent is within their clubhouse— just not on the field at the moment.
Bringing up George Lombard Jr. is the big trump card that New York had up their sleeve. They could have easily decided for him to finish 2026 at the minor league level, furthering his development with the future in mind. Instead, they took action and took a risk, naming a new shortstop to their ranks for the stretch run.
Since calling up Lombard Jr., the Yankees are 6-4. In the last 15 days, the Yankees have allowed just 28 runs to cross the plate against them. The second-best over that span is the Cardinals, with 42 runs allowed.
George Lombard Jr. made this throw look easy 👏 pic.twitter.com/RUylTeYqFD
— MLB (@MLB) August 18, 2026
It’s a rare case to make, but there is no denying that Lombard has brought an immediate impact at shortstop. His eight defensive runs saved largely inflate New York’s stellar pitching numbers.
An instant impact, and a clear message: it’s World Series or bust in 2026. The focus is on the current task, and the future is on pause for this fall. The best players will play, and the best team possible will be out on the field.
2 Comments