Two managers stood above the rest this season: John Schneider of the Toronto Blue Jays and Pat Murphy of the Milwaukee Brewers. Both led their teams to success through strong leadership, smart decisions, and consistent results.
American League: John Schneider, Toronto Blue Jays
The Blue Jays finally lived up to their potential in 2025, and John Schneider deserves the credit. Toronto’s lineup found balance, the pitching staff delivered, and the team played with confidence all year long.
Schneider handled the bullpen perfectly, kept the clubhouse loose, and got the most out of every player on the roster. Under his leadership, the Blue Jays went from question marks to legitimate contenders.
He’s the clear choice for American League Manager of the Year.
"It's cool to say you're playing for a country. East coast to West coast, everyone's pulling for this team." 🇨🇦
John Schneider on what it means for the Blue Jays to be Canada’s team. pic.twitter.com/NvHo2DkQHL
— Sportsnet (@Sportsnet) October 3, 2025
National League: Pat Murphy, Milwaukee Brewers
For the second straight year, Pat Murphy kept the Brewers among the National League’s best. Despite roster turnover and limited resources, he built a tough, disciplined team that played hard every night.
Milwaukee once again outperformed expectations and showed that Murphy’s leadership wasn’t a one-year fluke. His calm, confident approach continues to set the tone for one of baseball’s most consistent franchises.
Murphy should repeat as National League Manager of the Year.
Brewers manager Pat Murphy reflected on the Brewers loss putting them down 0-2 vs. the Dodgers in the NLCS:
Will the Brewers comeback and win the pennant? 🤔 pic.twitter.com/CfD5XmkLa8
— Strikeout Buzz (@StrikeoutBuzzX) October 15, 2025
Final Take
John Schneider brought Toronto’s talent together.
Pat Murphy kept Milwaukee’s success alive.
Two very different teams — one shared quality: elite leadership from the dugout.

4,155 Comments