Every franchise has that guy—the one who got away, bloomed somewhere else, or left a crater-sized hole when he walked. Whether it was a trade made too soon, a prospect misread, or a contract the front office blinked on, these are the players each fanbase would welcome back without hesitation.
New York Yankees — Juan Soto
One season was all it took. Soto transformed the lineup, balanced the order, and gave the Yankees the kind of generational left-handed bat they’ve chased for years. His patience, power, and October presence felt perfectly tailored for the Bronx. Letting him walk wasn’t just losing a star—it was losing an identity-changing player. Yankees fans would undo that in a heartbeat.
Boston Red Sox — Mookie Betts
This one still hurts. An MVP, a champion, and a homegrown superstar shipped out for financial flexibility. Fenway hasn’t been the same since.
Los Angeles Dodgers — Corey Seager
Yes, the Dodgers win a lot—but Seager was a franchise shortstop. Losing a World Series MVP in his prime still stings, even in L.A.
Chicago Cubs — Kris Bryant
The face of the 2016 title run. Injuries and timing muddied the ending, but Cubs fans would happily run it back with peak KB.
San Francisco Giants — Buster Posey
This one’s different. Posey retired on his own terms—but if the Giants could get one more season of their captain? They’d take it instantly.
St. Louis Cardinals — Albert Pujols (Prime Years)
The reunion tour was fun. The prime was legendary. Cardinals fans would choose 2005–2010 Pujols over almost anyone in baseball history.
New York Mets — Jacob deGrom
When healthy, he was the best pitcher on the planet. Mets fans don’t miss him—they miss the idea of him at full strength.
Toronto Blue Jays — Marcus Semien
Leadership. Power. Durability. Semien was the engine of the 2021 surge, and his absence is still felt.
Atlanta Braves — Freddie Freeman
A franchise icon who wanted to stay—and didn’t. Even with continued success, this one still feels unresolved.
Houston Astros — Gerrit Cole
He reached ace status in Houston, then cashed in elsewhere. Imagine pairing prime Cole with today’s Astros rotation.
Philadelphia Phillies — Chase Utley
Heart, edge, October magic. Phillies fans don’t just want Utley back—they want the vibe he brought with him.
Cleveland Guardians — Francisco Lindor
A superstar who grew up before our eyes. Trading him made sense financially—but emotionally, Cleveland never recovered.
Tampa Bay Rays — Evan Longoria
The Rays are ruthless with timing, but Longoria was the franchise. One more run in Tampa would’ve meant everything.
Seattle Mariners — Alex Rodriguez
Yes, it’s complicated. But prime A-Rod anchoring today’s roster? Seattle fans would sign that contract again in a heartbeat.
Milwaukee Brewers — Josh Hader
Elite relievers are hard to replace. Trading Hader sent a message—and the bullpen hasn’t felt as terrifying since.
Detroit Tigers — Justin Verlander
The comeback in Houston only made it hurt more. Detroit fans would love one more run with JV leading the staff.
Arizona Diamondbacks — Paul Goldschmidt
Consistent greatness. Quiet leadership. Goldy leaving left a hole that still hasn’t fully closed.
Texas Rangers — Adrian Beltre
Even with a title banner now flying, Beltre remains one of the most beloved Rangers ever. Prime Beltre was art.
Minnesota Twins — Johan Santana
In his prime, he was unhittable. Twins fans still dream about Santana headlining a modern postseason run.
Oakland Athletics — Matt Olson
Another homegrown star shipped out. Olson’s MVP-caliber seasons elsewhere are a constant reminder of what Oakland lost.
Final Thought
Every fanbase carries at least one “what if” like a scar. Some were business decisions. Some were miscalculations. Some were just bad luck.
But if you asked fans to rewrite one chapter of their franchise’s history—
they’d know exactly who to bring back.
59 Comments